Five Great Movies According to My Dad

For Father’s Day, I asked my dad to talk about his five favorite movies and he was up to the challenge.

This is my father

First there are some basics you should know about my father. He is a slightly bitter retired man who spends his nights watching the Nightly Business Report and the Newshour with Jim Lehrer. Since his retirement, he has taken up biking, playing solitaire, and occasionally woodworking. He hails from the Bronx and speaks with a fairly heavy New York accent. He loves Trisha Yearwood, Shania Twain, and Martina McBride, which makes no sense because he is from the Bronx. He has worked at a liquor store, an ice cream cart, a fish market and as a freight elevator operator. (But I won’t tell you which one had questionable mob ties.) He loves our cat, Salem, more than his four children combined (“Salem is the only one in this family who doesn’t bother me”). He hates lima beans and loves a good cannoli. In sum, my dad is ridiculous.

Our interview took place in my parents bedroom right before they went to bed. They were not too pleased that I bothered them. My mom tried to ignore us but she couldn’t resist interjecting some colorful commentary every now and then. After the interview I told my dad that he was about to blow up on the Internet. He replied, “Yeah. Whatever.”

So here they are. Enjoy and Happy Father’s Day!

1. A Bridge Too Far (1977)

Joe’s Reason: “The cast of actors. Action. Realism. Compelling story.”

2. From Here to Eternity (1953)

Joe’s Reason: “Historic. A good portrayal of characters. Compelling story.”

Mom’s Interjection #1:
“You already said that.”

3. To Kill a Mockingbird (1962)

Joe’s Reason: “What else can you say?”

4. American Graffiti (1973)

Joe’s Reason
Me: Because you’re a boy of the 60s?
Dad: Yeah.

Mom’s Interjection #2
Mom: What about Notting Hill? You’ve seen that like 10 times.
Me: He’s seen it way more than 10 times. He’s watches it every time its on.
Mom: I was being generous.

5. Notting Hill (1999)

Joe’s Reason: “Julia.”

Mom’s Interjection #3:
“He wishes he was Hugh Grant… or the roommate.”

With that I concluded the interview but then my dad kept talking.

Postscript from Joe #1:
Dad: How was that?
Me: Good. It wasn’t supposed to be deep.
Dad: Well, go to hell.

Postscript from Joe #2:
“I was going to picked Battle Cry but Joanna hasn’t heard of it. That was the Leon Uris book that got me started on reading all that crap. I think I had to study for a test but I finished the book instead and forgot to study for my test.”

Postscript from Joe #3:
“I also like that movie about Indiana.” (He means Breaking Away.)

Postscript from Joe #4:
“What did I pick?”

16 thoughts on “Five Great Movies According to My Dad”

    1. Thanks! The funniest thing is that my dad gets angry whenever there are lima beans in his food and then he bitterly transfers them to my plate. It happens every single time.

  1. Oh that’s all kind of lovable color commentary. My South Jouzey born-and-raised Italian pop was watching one of his predictable favorites on TV today, Goodfellas. I’m fairly certain his other four include at least two Godfathers and It’s a Wonderful Life but probably not Notting Hill. Man I love this idea of guest top 5 movie posts.. it should be a running CF series!

  2. This is my favorite blog post you have ever done. If not simply because I could literally hear him saying the quote about Salem..

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: